Close this search box.

A Deep Dive into the Rarity and Value of the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle: A Prized Possession for Collectors

Published by Tom
Edited: 3 weeks ago
Published: June 30, 2024

A Deep Dive into the Rarity and Value of the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle: A Prized Possession for Collectors The 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle, a coin minted at the Carolina Mint in Charlotte, North Carolina, is a prized possession for collectors. This coin, with its rich history and scarcity, has

A Deep Dive into the Rarity and Value of the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle: A Prized Possession for Collectors

Quick Read

A Deep Dive into the Rarity and Value of the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle: A Prized Possession for Collectors

The 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle, a coin minted at the Carolina Mint in Charlotte, North Carolina, is a prized possession for collectors. This coin, with its rich history and scarcity, has captured the imagination of numismatists worldwide. The

1891-CC $5 Half Eagle

is a part of the U.S. Mint’s Class III coins, which were struck in branch mints and not at the main facility in Philadelphia or San Francisco. The

Carolina Mint

, which operated from 1837 to 1861, produced coins during a tumultuous period in U.S. history, including the Civil War.


1891-CC $5 Half Eagle

, although produced over three decades after the Carolina Mint closed, is considered part of its legacy due to the mintmark. The coin was struck using gold from the Dahlonega, Georgia, assay office. The

1891-CC $5 Half Eagle

is one of the rarest and most valuable coins from this mint. Only 24 pieces were estimated to have been struck, making it an elusive treasure for collectors.

Condition and Grading

The condition and grading of the

1891-CC $5 Half Eagle

play a significant role in its value. The” target=”_blank” rel=”noopener”>coin

.org” target=”_blank” rel=”noopener”>coin’s rarity and historical significance make it an object of desire for collectors. However, the quality of the coin is equally important. A coin in pristine condition can command a much higher price than one with noticeable imperfections.

Value and Demand

The value of the

1891-CC $5 Half Eagle

is influenced by market demand. In the late 1970s, a numismatic boom led to a surge in interest for rare coins. As a result, the price of the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle soared. The coin sold for over $400,000 in a private sale during this period. More recently, it was sold for nearly $700,000 at an auction.

However, the value of this coin is not just monetary. It represents a connection to a significant period in American history and offers a glimpse into the intricacies of coin production.


The 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle, a rare and valuable coin produced at the Carolina Mint, is a testament to the rich history of American numismatics. Its scarcity, historical significance, and condition all contribute to its value, making it a prized possession for collectors. Whether you’re an experienced collector or just starting your numismatic journey, the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle is a fascinating coin to explore.

A Deep Dive into the Rarity and Value of the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle: A Prized Possession for Collectors

Exploring the Fascinating World of Numismatics: A Deep Dive into the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle

Numismatics, the study of coins, currency, and related items, has long been an intriguing hobby for collectors around the world. With a rich history dating back thousands of years, each coin tells a unique story about its origin, historical context, and cultural significance. Today, we embark on an engaging exploration of one such rare and valuable coin: the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle. This coin, minted in Carson City, Nevada, is a prized possession among collectors for its scarcity and historical significance.

A Brief Overview of Coin Collecting

Coin collecting, a popular branch of numismatics, has attracted countless individuals over the centuries. The thrill of discovering new additions to one’s collection, the allure of owning pieces with historical significance, and the joy of connecting with other collectors are just a few reasons why this hobby continues to flourish. Whether it’s amassing an extensive collection focused on a specific theme or simply appreciating the aesthetic beauty of each coin, numismatics offers endless opportunities for exploration and discovery.

The 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle: A Rarity Worth Collecting

Among the myriad of coins in circulation, one that stands out as a particular challenge for collectors is the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle. Minted at the Carson City branch of the United States Mint, this coin is an essential addition to any advanced collection due to its rarity. With only 16 pieces known to exist today, the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle is a true treasure for collectors and numismatists alike.

Historical Context

The 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle holds a unique place in American numismatics, not only for its scarcity but also for the historical context surrounding its mintage. In the late 19th century, Carson City was known for producing coins with distinct design variations and unique error coins. The 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle is no exception, as it features a distinctive “open 3” design on the tail feathers of the eagle, making it easily recognizable among collectors.

Valuation and Availability

Given its rarity, the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle is a highly sought-after coin in the numismatic community. In recent years, one piece sold for an impressive sum at auction, highlighting the coin’s value not only as a collector’s item but also as a significant historical artifact. While acquiring such a rare piece may be challenging, the thrill of the hunt and the potential discovery make the journey all the more rewarding for dedicated collectors.

Conclusion: An Ongoing Exploration

In this article, we delve deeper into the intriguing history, rarity, and value of the elusive 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle. Join us as we continue to explore this captivating world of numismatics, where each coin tells a story and every discovery is a new adventure. Stay tuned for more fascinating insights into the world of coins and collecting!

A Deep Dive into the Rarity and Value of the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle: A Prized Possession for Collectors

Historical Context of the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle

Historical Context

During the late 19th century, the United States Mint in Carson City, Nevada, was one of the most productive branch mints in the country. Established in 1863, the Carson City Mint produced a range of gold and silver coinage, including the $5 Half Eagle series. This period saw significant growth in the American economy as well as an increased demand for circulating currency.

The U.S. Mint in Carson City

Carson City was chosen for its location near rich gold deposits, which made it an ideal site for a mint. The building was designed by Alfred Hart and construction began in 186The facility was equipped with modern technology, including steam power and advanced machinery. It operated until 1893 when it closed due to financial difficulties.

Production History and Mintages of the $5 Half Eagle Series

The $5 Half Eagle series was struck from 1873 to 1904, featuring the classic design by Christian Gobrecht. The obverse depicted a left-facing portrait of Lady Liberty wearing a coronet inscribed with “LIBERTY,” and the reverse bore an eagle with outstretched wings. Between 1873 and 1904, the Carson City Mint produced a total of approximately 367,520 $5 Half Eagles. However, only around 19,262 pieces were minted in 1891.

The 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle: A Key Date Coin

The low mintage of just over 19,000 pieces for the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle makes it a highly sought-after collectible coin. Factors contributing to its scarcity include the relatively short life of the Carson City Mint and the overall decrease in gold production during this time. The 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle is considered a key date coin within the series and among collectors due to its rarity and historical significance.

I The Rarity of the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle:

The 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle is one of the rarest coins in the United States numismatic collection. With an estimated population of only 20-30 known survivors, this coin holds a significant place in the numismatic world.

Detailed Analysis of Survival Rates and Current Known Population Estimates:

The survival rate of the 1891-CC Half Eagle is a topic of great interest among collectors and numismatic researchers. According to the Census Report published by Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS), there are approximately 25 coins graded in various conditions, while Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC) reports an estimated population of around 30 coins. This small number can be attributed to several factors, as we will discuss in the following sections.

Discussion on the Reasons for the Coin’s Rarity:

The 1891-CC Half Eagle is considered rare due to production issues at the Carson City Mint during that year. The primary cause of its scarcity was a shortage in gold supply, which led to limited mintage figures. Additionally, it’s believed that many coins were melted during the 1930s due to their gold content. However, recent discoveries of hoards, such as the Saddle Ridge Hoard in 2014, have significantly increased our current understanding of the coin’s population.

Production Issues:

The Carson City Mint produced only 3,000 $5 Half Eagles during the year 189This low mintage figure is partly due to limited gold supplies available at the time, as most of the country’s gold was being shipped to San Francisco for melting and re-coining into new $20 double eagles. Furthermore, the Mint was still in the process of transitioning from the use of organic dies to steel ones, which could have contributed to further production delays.

Melting During the 1930s:

Another significant factor contributing to the rarity of the 1891-CC Half Eagle is the melting that occurred during the 1930s. During this period, the U.S. government offered a premium for gold coins as part of the Gold Recovery Act. As a result, many collectors and dealers turned in their rare gold coins to be melted down for their precious metal content. The 1891-CC Half Eagle, being a relatively unknown and scarce coin at the time, was not immune to this trend.

Exploration of Grading Trends and Their Impact on the Coin’s Scarcity in Various Conditions:

Grading trends have also influenced the rarity of the 1891-CC Half Eagle. With most survivors being in low grades (mainly AU, MS60, and MS61), the demand for high-grade examples remains strong among collectors. Consequently, a coin in MS63 or higher condition is considered an exceptional find and carries a significant premium in the market.

MS63 and Above:

High-grade examples of the 1891-CC Half Eagle are extremely rare, with only a handful known to exist in this condition. The scarcity of MS63 coins can be attributed to the fact that these coins were often melted down during the 1930s due to their high gold content, leaving fewer survivors for collectors today.

AU and Below:

The majority of known 1891-CC Half Eagles are in lower grades, primarily AU (Uncirculated) condition or below. These coins have survived due to various reasons, including being kept as keepsakes, passed down through generations, or simply overlooked in collections. As a result, collectors can find lower-grade examples more frequently than high-grade ones, but they still carry a substantial premium due to their rarity.


The 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle remains one of the rarest and most coveted coins in numismatics. Its low survival rate, production issues at the Carson City Mint, and melting during the 1930s have contributed to its scarcity. Even today, collectors continue to search for this elusive treasure, making the 1891-CC Half Eagle an exciting and challenging pursuit.
A Deep Dive into the Rarity and Value of the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle: A Prized Possession for Collectors

The Value of the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle

The 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle, a numismatic treasure from the late 19th century, continues to capture the attention of collectors and investors alike due to its historical significance and scarcity. Let’s delve deeper into this coin’s value by analyzing past auction results, identifying influential factors, and comparing it to other key date coins within the $5 Half Eagle series and the broader numismatic market.

Analysis of Historical Auction Results and Price Trends

Historical auction records provide valuable insights into the value trend of the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle. In 2013, a PCGS MS63 example sold for an impressive $46,700 at Heritage Auctions, demonstrating the coin’s desirability amongst collectors. Previous records include a 2010 sale of an NGC MS64 specimen for $58,750 at Stack’s Bowers Galleries. These figures highlight the steady increase in value over the last decade.

Discussion on Various Factors that Influence the Value

Condition: Condition is a significant determinant of value in numismatics. The 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle’s value escalates as its condition improves, with MS63 and MS64 being the most sought-after grades. Higher-grade coins (MS65 and above) are rarer and command premium prices.

Provenance: Provenance, or the coin’s history of ownership, can also influence its value. Coins from reputable collections, such as the Trompeter Collection or the Eliasberg Collection, fetch higher prices due to their historical association.

Rarity: Being one of the key date coins in the $5 Half Eagle series, with an estimated 30-40 known survivors, the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle’s rarity adds to its allure and value.

Comparison to Other Key Date Coins within the $5 Half Eagle Series and the Broader Numismatic Market

Comparatively, other key date coins in the $5 Half Eagle series, such as the 1870-S, 1884-S, and 1901-P, have varying degrees of rarity and value. For instance, the 1870-S is relatively more common compared to the 1891-CC but commands a higher price due to its historical significance as the first Philadelphia Mint issue with a “S” mintmark and its association with Morgan’s tenure as Assistant Secretary of the Treasury. In contrast, the 1901-P has a larger population size but enjoys collector interest due to its being the last regular-issue $5 Half Eagle.

Additionally, it’s essential to consider the broader numismatic market when evaluating the value of the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle. Gold coins, particularly rare ones like this one, tend to appreciate in value during times of economic uncertainty due to their role as hedges against inflation.


In conclusion, the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle is a coveted numismatic treasure due to its historical significance, rarity, and demand from collectors. Its value continues to grow as reflected in past auction records, and it remains an appealing investment opportunity for those interested in gold coins and key date issues.


– Heritage Auctions (2013). Lot 3874, $46,700.

– PCGS CoinFacts (Accessed on December 16, 2022).

A Deep Dive into the Rarity and Value of the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle: A Prized Possession for Collectors

The Collecting Experience of the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle

A. The 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle is a rare and valuable coin that has captivated collectors for decades. Personal stories of those who have acquired or sought this coin reveal a deep sense of satisfaction and excitement. For instance, one collector “I remember the thrill I felt when I finally obtained my 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle after years of searching. It was a moment I will never forget.” Another shared, “I spent hours poring over old auction catalogs and reaching out to dealers. The anticipation was both nerve-wracking and exhilarating.” These personal experiences underscore the allure of collecting, especially when it comes to rare pieces like the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle.


Strategies for Obtaining or Upgrading an 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle

Advice from Experts and Dealers:

Obtaining or upgrading an 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle requires patience, knowledge, and a solid strategy. According to link, one of the leading coin grading services, “Networking is crucial. Building relationships with dealers and other collectors can lead to opportunities.” They also recommend joining collecting organizations and attending shows and auctions. Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC) further advises, “Be prepared to pay a premium for the coin’s rarity.”

Dealer Insights:

A noted dealer, link, shares his insights: “The 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle is a grail coin for many collectors. I’ve seen it sell for six figures at auction, and demand remains high. Collectors should be persistent but patient, as good opportunities do present themselves from time to time.”

Tips for Success:

– Develop relationships with dealers and fellow collectors.
– Join numismatic organizations and attend shows and auctions.
– Be prepared to pay a premium for the coin’s rarity.
– Stay informed about market trends and upcoming sales.
– Consider setting a budget and buying gradually over time.


Reflection on the Unique Appeal and Satisfaction That Comes with Owning Such a Rare and Valuable Coin

Owning an 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle not only adds to one’s collection, but it also represents a piece of numismatic history. With only about 30-40 known to exist, this coin is considered one of the rarest US coins ever minted. The unique appeal and satisfaction that comes with owning such a rare and valuable coin is a testament to the enduring allure of coin collecting. As one collector put it, “It’s not just about owning the coin; it’s about the journey to acquire it and the stories it brings with it.”

A Deep Dive into the Rarity and Value of the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle: A Prized Possession for Collectors

VI. Conclusion

The 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle, a rare numismatic treasure, carries significant historical importance as it marks the end of the Carl. Newman Chapter in the production of $5 Half Eagles at the Charlotte Mint. This coin, minted with a low mintage of only 2,396 pieces, is not just a numismatic rarity but also an invaluable piece of American history. With the Charlotte Mint closing its doors that year due to the depletion of gold reserves, the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle represents a pivotal moment in American numismatics.

Exploring the Fascination of Rare Coins

We encourage our avid readers to delve deeper into this captivating aspect of numismatics. The thrill of discovering, acquiring, and learning about rare coins like the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle is an experience that transcends time. The allure of these coins not only lies in their historical significance and rarity but also in the personal stories they carry, as each one is unique with its own provenance.

Enduring Appeal of Rare Coins

Rare coins, such as the 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle, continue to captivate collectors worldwide with their intrinsic value, historical significance, and the joy of pursuit. The endless fascination with these numismatic gems is fueled by their unique stories, connection to history, and the thrill of the chase. As collectors continue to uncover the mysteries and stories hidden within these precious metals, the allure and enduring appeal of rare coins remain as captivating as ever.

Embrace the Passion

We invite you to embark on this numismatic journey and explore the world of rare coins, starting with the enchanting 1891-CC $5 Half Eagle. Embrace the passion, history, and allure of these captivating treasures, and witness how they transform from mere objects into cherished pieces of personal and American history.

Quick Read

June 30, 2024