Close this search box.

ETFs on the Rise: Could They Take Over Half of US Mutual Fund Assets?

Published by Elley
Edited: 1 month ago
Published: June 19, 2024

ETFs on the Rise: Could They Take Over Half of US Mutual Fund Assets? Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) have been making waves in the investment world, gaining significant popularity among both institutional and retail investors. ETFs offer several advantages over traditional mutual funds, such as transparency, liquidity, and lower expense ratios.

ETFs on the Rise: Could They Take Over Half of US Mutual Fund Assets?

Quick Read

ETFs on the Rise: Could They Take Over Half of US Mutual Fund Assets?

Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) have been making waves in the investment world, gaining significant popularity among both institutional and retail investors. ETFs offer several advantages over traditional mutual funds, such as transparency, liquidity, and lower expense ratios. According to a report by BlackRock, the world’s largest asset manager, ETFs could potentially capture up to half of US mutual fund assets within the next decade.

Why the Shift Towards ETFs?

Transparency: ETFs disclose their holdings on a daily basis, unlike mutual funds which only reveal their holdings quarterly. This transparency appeals to investors who want to know exactly what they are investing in.


ETFs offer greater liquidity compared to mutual funds. Investors can buy or sell ETF shares throughout the trading day on an exchange, while mutual fund investors typically have to wait until the end of the trading day to redeem their shares.

Lower Expense Ratios

ETFs generally have lower expense ratios than mutual funds due to their structure. Since ETFs are traded like stocks, they don’t require active management like mutual funds do. This translates into lower costs for investors.

Trends and Growth

According to a report by Cerulli Associates, assets in ETFs are projected to reach $7 trillion by 2030, up from around $5.7 trillion in 2019. This growth could potentially come at the expense of mutual funds, as investors increasingly turn to ETFs for their investment needs.

Impact on Mutual Fund Industry

If ETFs do manage to capture a significant portion of mutual fund assets, it could lead to significant changes in the mutual fund industry. Mutual funds would need to adapt to remain competitive, potentially offering more transparent and cost-effective products.


While it remains to be seen whether ETFs will actually take over half of US mutual fund assets, the trend towards ETFs is clear. With their advantages in transparency, liquidity, and lower costs, it’s not hard to understand why more and more investors are turning to ETFs for their investment needs.

ETFs on the Rise: Could They Take Over Half of US Mutual Fund Assets?

ETFs: The Future of Investing

Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs), a type of investment fund, have been gaining immense popularity among investors in recent years. An


is a collective investment scheme that holds an index, a commodity, bonds, or a basket of stocks in order to replicate the performance of an underlying benchmark index. The history of ETFs can be traced back to 1964 when the Amsterdam Exchange traded the “index fund” modeled on the Dutch stock market. However, it wasn’t until August 2001 that the first ETF was launched in the United States – the link (SPY).

In contrast to

Mutual Funds

, ETFs are traded like stocks on an exchange throughout the trading day. This feature allows for greater liquidity and more transparency compared to mutual funds, which are priced only at the end of each trading day. Furthermore, ETFs offer

lower expense ratios

due to their passive investment strategy and larger asset base.

Recent growth trends in the ETF industry have been


. Assets invested in ETFs hit an all-time high of $6 trillion in the second quarter of 2021, representing a 35% year-over-year increase. With their numerous advantages, including flexibility, lower costs, and greater transparency, ETFs are increasingly gaining traction in the investment world.

Thesis statement: Given their advantages,

ETFs are poised for further growth

, and it is not an exaggeration to suggest that they could potentially surpass half of the US link in the coming years.

Reasons for the Growth of ETFs

Cost Savings and Transparency

One of the primary reasons for the explosive growth of Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) over the last two decades is their cost savings and transparency advantages compared to traditional mutual funds.

Lower Expense Ratios

First, ETFs generally have lower expense ratios than mutual funds due to their unique structure. Since ETFs trade like individual stocks, they don’t require the same operational costs associated with buying and selling large blocks of securities as mutual funds do. This cost difference can amount to significant savings for investors over time, especially for those who hold their investments for extended periods.

Real-time Pricing and Intra-day Trading Capabilities

Second, ETFs offer investors real-time pricing and intra-day trading capabilities that mutual funds cannot match. This transparency allows investors to buy or sell ETFs throughout the trading day based on market conditions and price movements, giving them more flexibility and control over their investments.

Flexibility and Liquidity

Another major factor driving the popularity of ETFs is their flexibility and liquidity.

Ability to Buy and Sell ETFs Throughout the Trading Day

First, investors can buy or sell ETFs throughout the trading day, making them a more flexible investment option compared to mutual funds. This flexibility allows investors to react quickly to market changes and adjust their portfolios accordingly, potentially leading to better overall investment returns.

Wide Range of Investment Options

Second, ETFs offer a wide range of investment options, including sector-specific and thematic ETFs. This variety allows investors to build well-diversified portfolios that cater to their specific investment objectives, risk tolerance, and market outlook.

Tax Efficiency

Last but not least, ETFs offer tax efficiency advantages that mutual funds do not.

Lower Tax Implications due to In-kind Redemptions

First, ETFs facilitate in-kind redemptions, which means that investors can receive the actual securities held within an ETF instead of cash. This feature minimizes taxable events, as only the shares being redeemed are sold, reducing overall taxes paid compared to mutual funds.

Opportunities for Tax-loss Harvesting

Second, ETFs offer investors opportunities for tax-loss harvesting, as they can buy and sell individual securities within an ETF to offset capital gains or losses. This tax management strategy helps investors minimize their overall taxes, maximizing the after-tax returns on their investments.

ETFs on the Rise: Could They Take Over Half of US Mutual Fund Assets?

I Market Trends Supporting the Shift from Mutual Funds to ETFs

Institutional investment

Institutions, including pension funds and endowments, have been increasingly adopting ETFs as a preferred investment vehicle. The reasons are manifold: transparency, liquidity, and cost savings. ETFs allow institutions to easily track various market indices, while their tradability enables them to make quick adjustments to their portfolios.

Retail investor interest

Among retail investors, there is a growing number seeking lower-cost investment options. ETFs, with their lower expense ratios compared to mutual funds, have become an attractive choice for individual investors. Moreover, the easy accessibility of ETFs through online trading platforms and brokerages has made them increasingly popular among tech-savvy investors.

Industry consolidation

The ETF industry has seen significant consolidation, with mergers and acquisitions among providers leading to increased market share and scale. Additionally, partnerships between asset managers and index providers have expanded the range of investment options available to investors. These collaborations offer a wider array of strategies, such as smart beta and factor investing, further attracting assets away from mutual funds.

ETFs on the Rise: Could They Take Over Half of US Mutual Fund Assets?

Challenges for ETFs to Surpass Half of US Mutual Fund Assets

Regulatory Hurdles

One of the significant challenges ETFs face in surpassing half of US mutual fund assets lies in regulatory hurdles.

Potential Changes in Securities Regulations

Any alterations to securities regulations could impact ETFs differently than mutual funds, potentially introducing new complexities or costs. For example, Rule 6c-11, which requires ETFs to disclose large trades to the public in real time, could deter some investors due to heightened transparency. Conversely, modifications that ease regulatory burdens or streamline processes might attract more assets towards ETFs.

Infrastructure and Technology Requirements

Another challenge for ETFs to surpass mutual funds is the infrastructure and technology requirements.

Need for Advanced Trading Systems, Custodial Services, and Data Processing Capabilities to Support Growing ETF Volumes

ETFs demand advanced trading systems, custodial services, and data processing capabilities to manage growing volumes of assets. These investments can be costly for ETF providers, potentially acting as a barrier to entry or hindering smaller players’ competitiveness.

Adoption by Smaller Financial Institutions and Advisors

Finally, the adoption of ETFs by smaller financial institutions and advisors poses a considerable challenge.

Resistance from Smaller Players due to Perceived Complexity or Lack of Expertise in ETFs

Smaller players may be reluctant to adopt ETFs due to perceived complexity or a lack of expertise. To overcome this resistance, educational efforts and simplified investment solutions are essential. By fostering a better understanding of ETFs among smaller financial institutions and advisors, the asset class can expand its reach and potentially surpass mutual funds in terms of assets under management.

ETFs on the Rise: Could They Take Over Half of US Mutual Fund Assets?


In wrapping up our discussion, it’s essential to recognize the immense growth potential and advantages that Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) offer over traditional mutual funds. ETFs have revolutionized the investment landscape by providing transparency, liquidity, and cost efficiency that were once the exclusive domain of mutual funds. With the continuous innovation in ETF structures, investors can now access virtually any asset class or investment strategy through a single trade on an exchange.

Industry Trends and Challenges

However, it’s crucial to acknowledge that both asset classes face industry trends and challenges that could significantly impact their future. One such trend is the increasing preference for passive investing, with ETFs being at the forefront of this movement due to their lower costs and flexibility. In contrast, mutual funds have been under pressure to adapt, offering more customized solutions or focusing on areas where active management adds value.

Long-term Implications

Final thoughts

From an investor standpoint, these advancements mean more choice and access to various investment opportunities. However, it also necessitates a more informed decision-making process. Financial intermediaries have an essential role in guiding investors through this maze of options and helping them make the best decisions based on their risk tolerance, investment goals, and financial situation. On a broader scale, these trends could lead to significant structural changes in the investment management industry as a whole.

Impact on Intermediaries

Intermediaries might need to adapt their business models, focusing more on providing value-added services such as customized investment advice and risk management. They could also explore new revenue streams like asset management fees, trading commissions, or data analytics.

Regulatory Environment

Another factor to consider is the regulatory environment. Regulations like MiFID II in Europe and the evolving landscape of regulations in other parts of the world could impact how ETFs and mutual funds are marketed, traded, and managed. It is crucial for intermediaries to stay informed about these developments and adjust their strategies accordingly.

Continuous Innovation

Lastly, continuous innovation in technology and investment products will continue to shape the future of both asset classes. As investors demand more transparency, customization, and accessibility, providers must respond accordingly by offering innovative solutions tailored to their clients’ needs.

Quick Read

June 19, 2024